NYC Council Approves Buffer Zones Around Houses of Worships, Schools
The NYPD can set up buffer zones around synagogues and other houses of worship under legislation that the New York City Council passed Thursday, despite opposition from Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s DSA allies.
Measures 1-B and 175-B, advanced by Julie Menin, the council’s first Jewish speaker, empower the New York City Police Department to set limits on how close demonstrators can gather near entrances to synagogues, religious schools and similar institutions to ensure unobstructed and safe access.
Before the vote, Menin said that there was a 182% increase in antisemitic incidents in the city in January, and that churches had been vandalized and that there was a 69% increase in anti-Muslim hate crimes in 2024. “The increase in hateful acts across the city is absolutely abhorrent and we have to do something about it,” she said in a press conference.
1-B passed with a veto-proof majority of 44 out of 51 members, but 175-B, which addresses educational institutions, passed with 30 to 19, making it subject to a veto by the mayor.
Free speech advocates warned it threatens First Amendment rights, but Menin said it balances safety with rising antisemitism. “This is deeply personal. I am the daughter of a Holocaust survivor,” she said.
The bill requires the NYPD to plan for obstruction, injury, intimidation, or interference during protests, including whether security perimeters are needed. Menin introduced it after protesters chanting “globalize the intifada” descended on Park East Synagogue in November.
The measure follows Gov. Kathy Hochul’s push for 25-foot buffer zones and a prior Menin proposal for 100-foot perimeters, revised after NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch’s feedback. Mamdani has avoided taking a direct stance and is unlikely to veto it.
Progressive council members fought the bill. DSA member Shahana Hanif cited the 2020 summer protest agreement, warning it gives the NYPD too much power. Alexa Avilés said it does little to reduce hate and ignores community mistrust.
The NYC DSA also campaigned against this and a similar schools bill, while Hanif and Shekar Krishnan hosted a surprise Islamophobia briefing, angering Menin, who moved the buffer zone meeting to Council Chambers.
The package of measures passed today also included 22-A, which requires the city’s education department to distribute materials to students about the risks of social media and online hate; 297-A, which requires the mayor to establish an agency to provide religious and nonprofit institutions with support in establishing emergency plans; and 388-A, which establishes a hot line for reporting discrimination.

